PDA

View Full Version : Is buying SHARES allowed in ISLAM



taharoyal52
05-24-2012, 06:23 AM
doston! as salam o alaikum
mein yahan har roz aata hu to meri nazar shares par parti hay jis mein likha hota hay k 'we buy' and 'we sell'
dekh kar lagta hay aur mind kehta hay k shares kharid lo agay shares kay rate barhaingay aur is say acha profit hosakta hay.
Lekin mera dil kehta hay k 'nahi! yay allow nahi hay islam mein'

kya aap meri madad karaingay? please!
mujhe thora sa guide kardain. :sm21: :sm48:

Rizwan
05-24-2012, 03:05 PM
islam itna strict nae jitna logo nay is ko bna diya hei islam mein shars buy krna
koi gunah nae han short selling mein kuch complications hein jo molveh hzrat
kehty hein othr wise no problm in shars buy than sell

Farooq787
05-24-2012, 04:19 PM
Waqai Islam itna tang nazer mazhab naheen hay. Ab ap mujhay ye batain k silver aur gold purchase ker k rakhna jaiz hay ya naheen? Aur ici terha Grain Market walay sara saal different grains stock ker k rakhtay hain aur mehangi honay per baich daitay hain to kia ye bhi najaiz hay? Meray khiyal mein aisa naheen hay ager profit ho secta hay to loss bhi ho secta hay price below bhi ho jati hain.

adnan10076
05-25-2012, 04:01 AM
Islam to tang nazar nahi hay wo apny usoolon pe be chalta hay oor us tak ijazat deta hay...ab bath rahe shares ke to meny buht se places me deka hay jis me esko Islam ke nazar me haram kaha gya hay upto some extent...oor kuch jago par esko halal...lakin reason nahi talash krska...ab me eske search krunga k sure bath kia hy....

sarakhan
05-25-2012, 12:54 PM
i have heard from my Islamic banking teacher that share in some extent is haram, ham esy khredty es lie hy k near futuer main jub esky prices burhngy tho ham dobara baijh daingy,
i have also read answer of this question from this link. it may be helpful for all of u .
http://www.questionsonislam.com/question/share-market-permissible-islam

taharoyal52
05-25-2012, 05:47 PM
doston dekho
agar hum gold,silver buy kartay hay to hamari niyat yay hoti hay k hum isay pehnaingay wagairah
lekin hamari niyat kharab nahi hoti k hum next year ya hum baichay gay jub tak is kay rate barh jaingay

aur jub hum shares buy kartay hay toh hamari niyat yahi hoti hay k jub rates barh jaingay to hum isay baich dengy.

so, mere khayal say islam mein shares haram hay! (mein koi scholar nahi hu aur yay meri zati rai hay)

aur agar kisi dost kay pass reference ho to mujhe zaroor batayega!

featurelion
05-26-2012, 07:02 AM
bhai shares ka kaam heraam nehi hey, kunki yeh kaam puri dunya mein hota hey aur even k saudia arab mien bhi ho reha hey isi liye is ko haraam kehna ghelt hey aur ager kisi ko doubt hey to us ko chahiye woh share na purchase keray

aun
05-26-2012, 07:47 AM
Mery kahayl mein ahm two way trading kar rahy hoty hein .aik cheez sell kar rahy hoty ahein us kebadly mein dosri cheez buy kar rahy hoty hain to is ko izazat hai. baqi rahi Islam ki bat to is par zayad acomment nahin de sakta .Ye app kisi scholar se poochein.

sarakhan
05-26-2012, 08:29 AM
doston dekho
agar hum gold,silver buy kartay hay to hamari niyat yay hoti hay k hum isay pehnaingay wagairah
lekin hamari niyat kharab nahi hoti k hum next year ya hum baichay gay jub tak is kay rate barh jaingay

aur jub hum shares buy kartay hay toh hamari niyat yahi hoti hay k jub rates barh jaingay to hum isay baich dengy.

so, mere khayal say islam mein shares haram hay! (mein koi scholar nahi hu aur yay meri zati rai hay)

aur agar kisi dost kay pass reference ho to mujhe zaroor batayega!

yes bro i have read already in islamic banking.. our hamary teacher ny point clear krdi the k kuch hud tuk khram hy aur khram srf es wja sy k ham esy es neyat sy kharedty hyn k kal agr eski prcie burh gaye tho ham sell krdaingy, jis ka nature like sood ban jata.

taharoyal52
05-26-2012, 07:41 PM
yes bro i have read already in islamic banking.. our hamary teacher ny point clear krdi the k kuch hud tuk khram hy aur khram srf es wja sy k ham esy es neyat sy kharedty hyn k kal agr eski prcie burh gaye tho ham sell krdaingy, jis ka nature like sood ban jata.

haan mera dil aur dimag dono is baat say sehmat hay aur mujhe shares karidnay say rokta hay.
hamein har ek pal Allah ka shukr ada karna chahiyay kay woh hamesha hamein sahi raasta dikhata hay lekin kuch log galat raastay par bathak jatain hay :( aur phir galat kaam karlaytay hai :(

adnan10076
05-27-2012, 01:59 AM
wo tho teak hay ye to humny be suna hay kay kay some extent tak halal hay oor kuch had tak haram...magr ab ye dekna hoga kay kin surate hal ya kahan tak ye hala oor kahan tak ye haram hoga hmary lay...kiun kasy es trha to surety nahi hy na dil ko...

sarakhan
05-27-2012, 05:17 AM
some extant tuk haram hy tho es ka mtlabb yahi hy k hamy us neyat sy nhe khredna k kal agr price burh jaye tho main baich donga q k aisa kehny ka mtlab aisa he hy jaisy hum sood pa he baich rahy ho.

taharoyal52
05-27-2012, 09:59 AM
wo tho teak hay ye to humny be suna hay kay kay some extent tak halal hay oor kuch had tak haram...magr ab ye dekna hoga kay kin surate hal ya kahan tak ye hala oor kahan tak ye haram hoga hmary lay...kiun kasy es trha to surety nahi hy na dil ko...

mujhe to lagta hay yay bohat sara extent tak buying shares haram hay kyun k yahan hamari niyat bhi kharab hoti hay jab hum shares ko buy kartay hay isi wajah say yay completely haram hay!!!!

Mehak
05-27-2012, 10:15 AM
I think k shares lena haram ha, but I am not sure about it, as hum kam price ma letay hain and high per sell krtay hain, is sa hamari koi mehnat nhi hoti and zyada earning bhi ho jati ha, and shares sa aney wali money extra hoti ha.

waqasashraf17
05-27-2012, 04:23 PM
doston! as salam o alaikum
mein yahan har roz aata hu to meri nazar shares par parti hay jis mein likha hota hay k 'we buy' and 'we sell'
dekh kar lagta hay aur mind kehta hay k shares kharid lo agay shares kay rate barhaingay aur is say acha profit hosakta hay.
Lekin mera dil kehta hay k 'nahi! yay allow nahi hay islam mein'

kya aap meri madad karaingay? please!
mujhe thora sa guide kardain. :sm21: :sm48:



ma es k baray ma zaida information nhjanta magar meray khail ma hamain jahan es ko disccuss nh karna chaiyay kyu k es ki baray ma ap ko mukhtlif ideas milay gay jo k logo ko ak dosray k khilaf kar saktay hain.

ali1011
05-31-2012, 02:11 AM
I think k shares lena haram ha, but I am not sure about it, as hum kam price ma letay hain and high per sell krtay hain, is sa hamari koi mehnat nhi hoti and zyada earning bhi ho jati ha, and shares sa aney wali money extra hoti ha.

mery keyhayl sy aisa nhi ho sakta ku k yeh aik business hy is me share ka rate kam be to ho sakta hy is me zarori to nhi hy k share ka rate barhta he jay yeh kam be ho sakta hy is liye mery kheyal sy is me koi problme nhi hy k yeh hram ho Islam me .

featurelion
05-31-2012, 02:37 AM
is sewaal ka jewaab halal hey us ki reason yeh hey k ager yeh haram hota to saudia mein bhi stock share purchase na ho rehay hotay jo k pure islamic country hey, kehna ka metlab hey k yeh kaam her jega phel geya hey or pakistan mein ager haraam hota to yeh openly na ho reha hota.. chhup ker ho reha hota

Dangerous
05-31-2012, 05:10 AM
is sewaal ka jewaab halal hey us ki reason yeh hey k ager yeh haram hota to saudia mein bhi stock share purchase na ho rehay hotay jo k pure islamic country hey, kehna ka metlab hey k yeh kaam her jega phel geya hey or pakistan mein ager haraam hota to yeh openly na ho reha hota.. chhup ker ho reha hota
Yaar konsa kam yahan chup ker hota ha , well shares ko buy kerna haram is leye nahi ha in my view there is fix thing like is forum perbb shares hain lekan uski r eason ye ha k as member or posts grow kareen gein to he apko profit miley ga otherwise shares ap k leye kam nahi karenn gein

manibhai2012
05-31-2012, 05:30 AM
Yes my dear you can buy shares and it is allowed in Islam it is totally called halal in Islam so don't be panic try to invest in mutual sharing programs it can give you profit also.

Rizwan
05-31-2012, 06:01 AM
i have heard from my Islamic banking teacher that share in some extent is haram, ham esy khredty es lie hy k near futuer main jub esky prices burhngy tho ham dobara baijh daingy,
i have also read answer of this question from this link. it may be helpful for all of u .
http://www.questionsonislam.com/question/share-market-permissible-islam

buy sharing bikul jaiz hei hei lekin kuch molve keht hein key jo cheez ap buy
kro wo phsycal bhe ap kay pas honi chhye lekin is technolgy periode mein
ab molvie bhe kuch chang ho rhy hein ab keht hei kay buying jaiz hei

adnankhan
05-31-2012, 06:09 AM
islam ma o kam tek nae ha jo ap store k neyat sa krte ho matlb ap koi cheez market ma late ha or ap sochte ho k time acha ho jae or ya profit k lia store karte ho to o kam tek nae ha or share ma be zayda tar e hesab ho ta ha is lia log kahte ha k ye tek nae ha

sherani
05-31-2012, 07:29 AM
ya mazahab say motalek hai.es bary may mujh khas malomat nahi hain.agar kio bat ghalt ho gy.tuo gonah hota hai.ya may kesi allem say poch lon ga.aur pr yahan ap say share karun ga...

taharoyal52
05-31-2012, 01:09 PM
ya mazahab say motalek hai.es bary may mujh khas malomat nahi hain.agar kio bat ghalt ho gy.tuo gonah hota hai.ya may kesi allem say poch lon ga.aur pr yahan ap say share karun ga...

Sahi keh rahay ho aap. Yahan agar aap nay kuch tukkay mein keh diya to aap ko gunah hojaiga.

Mein intazaar karuunga jab tak apnay aalim say puch nahi letain. Please bhoolna mat. Yahan humsay woh share karlayna ta k hum sab gunah karnay say mehfooz hojai!!

Thanks in advance. aap kay reply ka intazaar karoonga.

petrelsea70
05-31-2012, 02:42 PM
islam itna strict nae jitna logo nay is ko bna diya hei islam mein shars buy krna
koi gunah nae han short selling mein kuch complications hein jo molveh hzrat
kehty hein othr wise no problm in shars buy than sell

dear i m business student and i know share are not haram in islam ,u can buy share that company which business is not base on haram things

petrelsea70
05-31-2012, 02:43 PM
han yar molviaon ne islam ke image khrb kr dia hai ye log islam ko sekht bna kr is ka rong image day reh hain,islam me share halal hain

taharoyal52
06-01-2012, 01:16 PM
han yar molviaon ne islam ke image khrb kr dia hai ye log islam ko sekht bna kr is ka rong image day reh hain,islam me share halal hain

nahi! sab molviyaan kharab nahi hotay. kuch achay abhi baki hay jinho nay abhi tak islam ko tutnay say bachaya hay.
warna agar woh achay molvi's agar na hotay to islam kab ka divide ho chuka hota aur bikhar chuka hota.

ali1011
06-02-2012, 02:26 AM
bhai shares ka kaam heraam nehi hey, kunki yeh kaam puri dunya mein hota hey aur even k saudia arab mien bhi ho reha hey isi liye is ko haraam kehna ghelt hey aur ager kisi ko doubt hey to us ko chahiye woh share na purchase keray

bhai aisa hy hram to tab ho ga k jab is me ap ko loss he na ho mujhy nhi lagta hy k yeh hraam hy is me na to apko interest pay karty hen na he koi fix profit hy k ap ney invest kr dia apko itnay percent milay ga fix or is me to rate barhta be hy kam be hota hy yeh haraam nhi ho sakta.

mombati
06-02-2012, 02:34 AM
jub companies share issue krti hy tho us ka mtlab apny business ko vast krna na k zyda pice ya kam price ki wja say wo share issue krty hyn lakin mera nhe khyal ye islam main khram hyn q k aksr esy us situation main bhi sell kr deya jata hy jub company ki financial position bad ki traf jarahi hoti hay,

sonu
06-02-2012, 06:02 AM
sir wese mujhe lagta hai ke ye aik business hai shares ka to mujhe confarm nahi hai magar forex trading to islam me allowed hogi kyun ke ye trading hai aur trading to islam me be jaiz hai

kazim
06-05-2012, 03:57 AM
doston! as salam o alaikum
mein yahan har roz aata hu to meri nazar shares par parti hay jis mein likha hota hay k 'we buy' and 'we sell'
dekh kar lagta hay aur mind kehta hay k shares kharid lo agay shares kay rate barhaingay aur is say acha profit hosakta hay.
Lekin mera dil kehta hay k 'nahi! yay allow nahi hay islam mein'

kya aap meri madad karaingay? please!
mujhe thora sa guide kardain. :sm21: :sm48:

bahi jan muja es ka bara min kcuh knowledge nahi ka ka share islam main jazaa han ka najaza han muja es ka bara main kuch knwoldge nahi ha ksi expert sa jawab managa ho skata ha koi achi or best news maila jay.

aslamkarezi
06-07-2012, 07:39 AM
i think aisey maslay ka solution poochnay ka sab se betreen jaga /tariqah ye ha keh banda kisi aalim se ja kr is baray me pooch lian keh shares purchase/sale halaaal ha or haram? ap ko yahan se valid answer mushkil ha amilay.

adnankhan
06-07-2012, 08:57 AM
asal ma islam ma kesi cheez ko rate ka lia store karna sahe nae ha jis ki waja sa shares ko teek nae smja jata mager ma khud aik bat soch raha ho k is ma to profit or loss dono ha pir pata nae kue ye kesi sahe mufti sa pochna ho ga

mombati
06-07-2012, 02:01 PM
Mere khyal say tho es main koi aisy khram wali bath nhe hay kioun kay aksr jub aik company insolvent hojata hay tho wo apni companies kay share sell karta hay thakay benfits hasil karsky future main, ya per complete khtam karny k lie company ell out hojati hay. so us situation main tho zror us kay share bnda khreedy ga.

fozia
06-07-2012, 03:32 PM
well yeh bat darust hai kay Islam inta sakht aur tang nazar religion nhi hai. jahan tak shares ko buy and sell karnay ki bat hai tu maine aksar logo say suna ha kay yeh haram hai in Islam and kuch log kehtay han kay yeh allow hy. i am not too sure about this magar main jananay ki koshish kaurn g.

shoaibawan
06-07-2012, 06:42 PM
ya to aik critical sa point ha main apnay pass say nahe kah sakta kay ya islam main hlal ha ya hram ha i think kay is kay liay best ya ha kay kisi Aalim e islam say Quran o ahadess ki roshni main discuss kia jay so i think this is better way to know purchasing or buying shares is allowed or not in islam

m.arfanzahid
06-07-2012, 06:53 PM
islam main shares purchase krna halal he pr is surat main k ap us ka profit ya loss earn kro ge. agr is lye purchase kro k rate brhne pr sale kr do ge to ye halal nhi he. I have strong comment about it. mene ye kisi book main prha he.

taharoyal52
06-07-2012, 07:24 PM
well yeh bat darust hai kay Islam inta sakht aur tang nazar religion nhi hai. jahan tak shares ko buy and sell karnay ki bat hai tu maine aksar logo say suna ha kay yeh haram hai in Islam and kuch log kehtay han kay yeh allow hy. i am not too sure about this magar main jananay ki koshish kaurn g.

mere nazariyay say aur mere molvi sahab nay bhe yay kaha hay k buying/selling of shares is strictly prohibited in islam. kyun k yahan phir aap ki neyat sirf profits ki hi hoti hy k agr jaysay rates uper jaingay mein sell kardunga wagairah.
so for me i cant buy and sell shares

shiekh saim
06-10-2012, 11:37 AM
Islam to tang nazar nahi hay wo apny usoolon pe be chalta hay oor us tak ijazat deta hay...ab bath rahe shares ke to meny buht se places me deka hay jis me esko Islam ke nazar me haram kaha gya hay upto some extent...oor kuch jago par esko halal...lakin reason nahi talash krska...ab me eske search krunga k sure bath kia hy....

bay shak ISLAM ma share ko haram karar dia hoa ha likin ISLAM ma toa sooad ko b haram qarar dia hoa ha likin agr yahi baat aap 1 bankert say pocho gy toa wo aap ko baohat c batain suna a ga likin os k batain sunany c sooab halal toa nahi hoa ja a ga na isi tarhan agr share haram qarrar dia ha toa ya bdl nahi skta ha kabi b

multinet
06-10-2012, 02:30 PM
doston! as salam o alaikum
mein yahan har roz aata hu to meri nazar shares par parti hay jis mein likha hota hay k 'we buy' and 'we sell'
dekh kar lagta hay aur mind kehta hay k shares kharid lo agay shares kay rate barhaingay aur is say acha profit hosakta hay.
Lekin mera dil kehta hay k 'nahi! yay allow nahi hay islam mein'

kya aap meri madad karaingay? please!
mujhe thora sa guide kardain. :sm21: :sm48:

bahi jan ya to muja pata nahi ha k sahare islam main allow han ka nahi han main koi maulvi nahi hoon agr ap na kuch maloomat eanred karni ha to ap kis alam sa laya sakta hoo.

taharoyal52
06-10-2012, 07:05 PM
bay shak ISLAM ma share ko haram karar dia hoa ha likin ISLAM ma toa sooad ko b haram qarar dia hoa ha likin agr yahi baat aap 1 bankert say pocho gy toa wo aap ko baohat c batain suna a ga likin os k batain sunany c sooab halal toa nahi hoa ja a ga na isi tarhan agr share haram qarrar dia ha toa ya bdl nahi skta ha kabi b

han woh log jhut bol kar phir kehtay hay k aysa ha aur waysa hay.
jab maynay maulvi sahab say pucha to phir unho nay mujhay bohat daanta aur kaha k haan bilkul shares allow nahi hay islam mein. sakht mana hay.
unho nay waja yay bataye k hamari intention sirf phir profit ki hoti hay jo k galat hay.

m.arfanzahid
06-11-2012, 05:43 AM
han woh log jhut bol kar phir kehtay hay k aysa ha aur waysa hay.
jab maynay maulvi sahab say pucha to phir unho nay mujhay bohat daanta aur kaha k haan bilkul shares allow nahi hay islam mein. sakht mana hay.
unho nay waja yay bataye k hamari intention sirf phir profit ki hoti hay jo k galat hay.

bhai main ap ki bat se itfaaq nhi krta. ap sirf profit ki bat kr rhe hain to shares main b to loss hota he. to hr wo cheez jo ap physically buy ya sell krte ho or ap ko profit or loss dono ka chance ho to wo halal he.
or mene b is bare main prha he kafi. agr ap shares hold krte ho or annual dividend receve krte ho usi company se to halal he. agr ap is lye buy krte ho k main dubara sell kr k profit earn kru ga to halal nhi he.

gulking
06-11-2012, 08:22 AM
es ka itna masla nai hain main na kaffie jaga pata kiya hain or mujy ya he pata laga hain ky es tarha sood banta hain ky hm sochty hain share jb barien gain tb sell kr dain gain es tarha ya sood ban jata hain mujy jitna pata tha main na bata diya hain or koe mujy detail sy bata sakta hain mairy post per reply kr ky

Mehak
06-11-2012, 08:45 AM
shares buy krna k baray ma Islam ma kahin haram ka zikar to nhi ha, but is ka profit sood ki tarhan ka ha and Islam ma sood haraam ha, k humzyada profit per shares sell krtay hain, or hum us pofit kliya koi effort nhi krtay, and without effort apko jo money milega wo haram hi hoga.

shiekh saim
06-11-2012, 10:54 AM
islam itna strict nae jitna logo nay is ko bna diya hei islam mein shars buy krna
koi gunah nae han short selling mein kuch complications hein jo molveh hzrat
kehty hein othr wise no problm in shars buy than sell

ya brother i agree with u ISLAM ma kahin nahi likha ha k share buy gunah ha bas jiss ko kisi say koi jelising feel hoti ha wo os kaam ko gunah kah daita ha or agr osi k pas paisy hoon wo kaam karny k lia toa tab toa wo kaam theek oa jata ha bas aaj kal har insaan k darmayan compitation chal raha ha k kon zayada bhara ha har koi isi baat py hota ha k ma apny aap ko bahra kar loa

sammar
06-11-2012, 12:43 PM
islam shares ko khrdiny say rokhta hia jis min gamling ka asar ho ais baat say islam rokhta jiss say kasi admi ki nuqsan ho jay aour aik ko profit ho jay aik dam . ais lay share min bhee gamiling ka chance hota hia ais lay isalm mana karta hia. aour share ki tarding say ajtnab karna cheiy.

mombati
06-11-2012, 03:22 PM
agr haram hoty tho phir tho koi compny bhi esy neh khredty as muslmaan buhat zyada log aisy abhi bhi mojod hay jo kharam activity ko remove krny ki koshesh tho krty hyn lakin eski mesal bhi tho aik trading ki trah he hay jub aik compny loss main jaruhi hoti hy aur wo apny qarzy pora krna chati hy tho apny share bach daiti hay. so es point of view say tho mujy nhe lgta khram hay albta agr koi es maqsad k lie ly ky kal agr prices burh gaye phir baich daingy tho phir khram hay.

taharoyal52
06-13-2012, 11:57 AM
Muje to lagta hay k shares buy karna is haram. kyun k shares buy kartay waqt hamari neyat he hoti hay k profits ho. aur hum shares ko jab sell kartay hay jab profits hota hay. us say pehlay nahe.
lekin yay depend karta hay. koi kehta hay haan aur koi kehta hay na!

petrelsea70
06-13-2012, 07:33 PM
Islam me share HALAL hai koi b in ko haram nhi keh skta ,wo business jo HALAH product produce kar reh hain us company k share ap buy kar sktye hain is me koi masla nhi lakan kch companies HALAL producets nhi produce kar rahi hoti to ap wo buy nhi kar skte

shiekh saim
06-14-2012, 02:56 AM
daikhan mujy is baaat k bary ma zayada knowledge toa nahi ha likin itna zarror kah skta hoon k islam ma itni strickness nahi ha jitna btae gae ha
wasy jahn jahn tak maira khayal ha k shares is allow in islam ku k mainy toa aaj tak kahin b nahi parha ha k shares are not allowed in islam
agr yahi baat ha tab toa sooad b not allowed likin log laity hain tab kahn hota ha on ka islam ?????

adnankhan
06-14-2012, 03:14 AM
ma na jahan tak suna ha islam ma o karobar tek nae ha jis ma ap kesi chez ko rate k lia store karte ho or share ma to loss be ha or profit be mager pir be kesi ache mufti sa pochna ho ga

m.arfanzahid
06-14-2012, 04:45 AM
ma na jahan tak suna ha islam ma o karobar tek nae ha jis ma ap kesi chez ko rate k lia store karte ho or share ma to loss be ha or profit be mager pir be kesi ache mufti sa pochna ho ga

ap ne thek kaha
agr hm rate k lye buy krte hain k is ka rrate zyada hote hi sell kr den ge to not allowed pr agr ap is lye buy krte ho k company k profit or loss main se hisa mile ga to phr allowed he.

ali1011
06-17-2012, 09:16 AM
shares buy krna k baray ma Islam ma kahin haram ka zikar to nhi ha, but is ka profit sood ki tarhan ka ha and Islam ma sood haraam ha, k humzyada profit per shares sell krtay hain, or hum us pofit kliya koi effort nhi krtay, and without effort apko jo money milega wo haram hi hoga.

sood k bary me to islam me boath he sakhti sy mana kiya gy hy iska gunah be boaht ziada hy aik hadees mubarika me irshad hy: jis ney sood khaya goya uska gunaah aisa hy k jaisa us ney apni maa k sath 35 martba zina kia . agar to yeh sood hy to haemn api akhirat ko sanwarny k liye is sy bachna chaiye ALLAH PAK hame iski tofeeq dy .ameen

adnankhan
06-17-2012, 10:12 AM
jahan tak muja pata ha islam ma har o kam tek nae ha jo ap store k neyat sa karte ho mager share ma to loss or profit dono hote mager pir be kesi ache mufti sa pochna ho ga

altafa50
06-17-2012, 01:23 PM
jahan tak meray ilm or mojhey jo information mili hai to us se ya baat samney ayi hai ke SHARES KA KAROBAR JAIEZ NAHI or is ki buy or sell jaiez nahi ,ku ke karobar ka tariqa ya hai ke jo cheez app buy or sell karahy hain .us ka hona yani ke app us cheez ko apney hath se use karsakty ho.jesy je cloth ,gold chandi wagera.call 03332470633

taharoyal52
06-17-2012, 07:56 PM
jahan tak meray ilm or mojhey jo information mili hai to us se ya baat samney ayi hai ke SHARES KA KAROBAR JAIEZ NAHI or is ki buy or sell jaiez nahi ,ku ke karobar ka tariqa ya hai ke jo cheez app buy or sell karahy hain .us ka hona yani ke app us cheez ko apney hath se use karsakty ho.jesy je cloth ,gold chandi wagera.call 03332470633

han yar! islam mei sakhat mana hay shares ko buy ya sell karnay ka.
thanks for informing. mei thora confuse hogaya tha.

shahnawaz009
06-18-2012, 12:23 AM
walaikum salam bhai ap ke shares ka idea to acha hai lekin jab islam ki baat ati hai to mera mashwara hai k ap kisi achai aalim k pass jao or unse sai mashwara talab karo kyun k ap ko wohi behter guide karenge....

shiekh saim
06-18-2012, 03:23 AM
jahn tak maira khayal ma k ISLAM ma shares buying karny ma koi pabandi nahi ha ku k agr ham koi cheez buy kar k os ko apna profit rakh k sale kar daity hain toa is ma borae hi kya ha
or mairy khayal say toa ISLAM ny insaan ko profit kamanay say toa kabu b nahi roka ha

khalidmeer
06-22-2012, 07:25 AM
Mjhay is baaray main itni knowledge nahi is liye i should keep quiet.

aslamkarezi
06-22-2012, 08:59 AM
bhot sary log shares buy and sale krte hain, i do not think keh is baray me islam be koyi pabandi ho gi, keh shares ka karobar haram ho ga...i halaal hain.

fozia
06-22-2012, 09:08 AM
Islam to tang nazar nahi hay wo apny usoolon pe be chalta hay oor us tak ijazat deta hay...ab bath rahe shares ke to meny buht se places me deka hay jis me esko Islam ke nazar me haram kaha gya hay upto some extent...oor kuch jago par esko halal...lakin reason nahi talash krska...ab me eske search krunga k sure bath kia hy....
yes i agree with you ke islam me itni restriction nahi hain jitni aaj kal logo ne baten banaye hui hain. maine bhi kahin jaga pe suna hai ke shares lena or dena haram hain or kuchlog is ko nahi manty. maine tab tak koi answer nahi day sakti jub kab khud satisfied na hon.

wahaj
06-22-2012, 09:44 AM
walekum As SAlam..
bht se log shares main confuse hote hain k yeah Islam main allow hai ya nh
aur hamain is k kisi aalim se poochne chaie...ya kisi ko pta hai toh mjhe bhi plx btade
REPLY???

petrelsea70
06-22-2012, 09:45 AM
yes,islam me shares ke trading krna halal hai or koi b person share ko but kar skta hai kiun k is me risk hai.jo compnaies halal business karti hain un k ap share buy kar ste ho or un ko sale kar skte hin or pana profit margin nikal skte hain or is lie Islam shares allowed karta hai

Arsalan.Antique
06-22-2012, 10:08 AM
Hey Joseph !! well shares are what ?? its like a property ryt ?? the house in whch u live ryt now may be your father hav perchased it of 5 lacs .. !! now the value of your house might be 20 or 30 or 40 lacs !! if your father gets a new house .. are you gonna sale your old house at 5 lacs only ?? think for it !!

samar
06-22-2012, 10:25 AM
Shares is allowed in islam and there is no doubt about the dealing of shares, jo kuch Quran me saaf saaf likh dia ke wo haaram ha wo haaram ha aur jis ke bare me nahi likha us me koi kabahat nahi.

Ashu
06-22-2012, 10:57 AM
well i dont think so! share cant be haram! its a type of business! ppl trade with it! then work hard and keep their eye at points scale! and thats work! haram is that thing is which physically nothng is workd!

shiekh saim
06-22-2012, 11:31 AM
g han ISLAM ma shares buying karna jaiz ha ku k share sale or buy karna koi haram kaam nahi ha joa k ISLAM hamain is kaam say roky ya kah loa k aik bussines ha or koi b bussines ISLAM ma haram nahi ha swa a SOOAD khany k

Saadgader
06-22-2012, 12:52 PM
Mere khayaal se hum me say kisi ko bhi is baarey me behas nahi karni chahiye, hamey chahiye ke hum kisi AALIM or MUFTI se maloom karey, wo hi hamey sahi or achi tarah guide karenge.

huzefakaizer
06-22-2012, 04:52 PM
no no no! islam sirf ek religion hay. islam nay kabhi ijazat nahe dei forex shares aur any types of shares kharidnay ke kyun k its not allowed. i dont believe in shares. i just do my best here.

imran munawer
06-25-2012, 10:19 AM
jii sub dostoon ki baat parhi lakin masla wahin ka wahin ha .dakhain hum koi bhi kam is liya jaiz karar nahi da sakta ka wo pori duniya ma ho raha ha ya suaidiy ama bhi ho raha ha.its not reason asa tu or boaha hain.masla ya ha ka isa kisi sahi baamal alim sa detail sa pocha jaya .hut sa haram kam duniya ma ho r

shiekh saim
06-25-2012, 11:39 AM
mujuy is bary ma zayada knowledge toa nahi ha likin jahn tak mujy lgta ha ISLAM ma buying share allowd hain ku k ya koi buri cheez nahi ha joa ISLAM is say mana kary hmain baki KHUDA bhtar janta ha

Kashif
07-02-2012, 05:56 PM
share purchase karna haaram hai q k agar ap kise islamic banking main amount rakhty hai to wo apko ziyada kuch bhe nahi dety hai wohi ammout apko wapis karty hai! & shares hum khareedty kum paiso se hai aur ziyada karny k liye usay ziyada paiso se bechty hain!

waqar12
07-02-2012, 06:52 PM
haan app nay theek kaha bphat say log ya hi samjhtay hain k sharex ka kam haram ahi par aisa nhai hai islam main is ki ijazat hai kyoo k iss main nuksan or faida doonoo hai haan wo kam haram hai jiss mian sirf faida ho nuksan na hoo

huzefakaizer
07-02-2012, 06:52 PM
dekho agar aisi baat hai to islam mai to bohat si chizo ka mana kiya huwa hai us mai hum islam ko beach mai nahi lay kar atay hai per jab business ki baat aati hai to hum molvi ban jatay hai

Maria Arsalan
07-02-2012, 06:55 PM
han islam mn shares khareedny par koi mumaniyat nhi hai ye ek trade hai or trade islam mn hota hai
ghr bar chalany k liye

shiekh saim
07-03-2012, 11:14 AM
g han jahn tak maira khayal ha ISLAM ma share buy karna theek ha ku k agar ham kisi cheez ko buy karty hain or fhr achi keemat ma sale kar daity hain toa is ma buri baat kya ha /???????????

0346
07-03-2012, 11:19 AM
bhai shares ka kaam heraam nehi hey, kunki yeh kaam puri dunya mein hota hey aur even k saudia arab mien bhi ho reha hey isi liye is ko haraam kehna ghelt hey aur ager kisi ko doubt hey to us ko chahiye woh share na purchase keray

adeel
07-03-2012, 05:22 PM
acha is that so tou please meri bhi help karein brother aur mujhaay bhi is mamlay mai guide k whether it is allowed in islam or not plz mer bhi help i also want to know whether it is right or wrong according to islam

sher abbas
07-03-2012, 06:58 PM
buying and selling of shares in Isalm are acceptable not forbidden mager is baat ka khayal rakha jay ki jo shares aap khraed rahy hen wo ksi halal company ki sahre ho, ksi wine production company, ksi interest base company ke shares men aap transction ni kr skty or boht sari principles hen jin ky mutabiq aap trading kr skty hen.

sher abbas
07-03-2012, 07:03 PM
shares ki khraeed or faurkht bilkul halal hy Islam men mager kuch sharayet ke sath,,
shares ksi wine production company ki na ho
shares ksi interest base company ke na ho
shares jo aap khreed rahy hen wo aap ke postion men ay than aap agy sell kr skty hen yani short selling haram hy.
Future trading ke sath b haram hy
baqi halal companies ky shares ki trading kr skty hen or halal hy

waqasashraf17
07-03-2012, 07:50 PM
mery khyal me islam me boht relaxation hy itna sakht nahi hy bs problm ye hy k hmy kisi b bat k bary me proper knoldge nahi hota or hm agy barhaty rehty hen ye bat nuqsan daiti hy k log theek ko galt or galt ko theek smjty hen

Kashif
07-03-2012, 09:03 PM
mery khayal se ye apko koi acha sa muslim he bata sakta hai jisny complete "QURAN SHAREEF" recite kiya ho hamen to is chez ka pata nahi hai, k ye allow hai ya nahi islam main & islam main aur bhe chezain hai jo allow nahi hai par wo hum karty hai,!

MUHAMMAD0622
07-04-2012, 11:04 AM
i think k humain apna personal opinion nahi dena chahiye k aya yeh haram hai ya nahi islam mai n i think k apko kisi well knwn madrasay ja k wahan mufti se mil k yeh sawal kerna chahiye q k mayb yahan koi utni knwldge na ho but hr 1 apna opinion dy jis se mamla mazeed confucing hoga

shiekh saim
07-05-2012, 08:18 AM
g han shares buying are allowed in ISLAM ku k ya koi bura kaam nahi ha joa k ISLAM hmain is say roky is lia mairy khayal say toa allowed ha

khalidmeer
07-05-2012, 08:49 AM
Sab ney bilkul sahi kaha hai ISLAM main itni restricitions nahin hain sirf basic cheezain hain , jo aaj kal ke ulemas ne shares aur Forex and stock ko galat declare kar diya hai

Kashif
07-08-2012, 05:48 PM
ye to kise aese aadmi se pochna parega jo is chez k baary main janta ho mera khayal se shares kharedna allow nahi hai islam main q k ye bhe gambling ki tarah hia ap kum amount main share buy karty ho aur usay phir sell ziyada amount se karty ho!

rehman0332
07-08-2012, 05:55 PM
han ye bat to he ke shres ham muslamano ke lye haram he magar agar ham pese ko dekty he to hamy sab se acha tarika shre hi lagta he aur hm is me apna pesa laga dete he ye bat to ap bhi janty he ke shres aj dunya me numer one ja raha he

fozia
07-08-2012, 06:02 PM
main still confused hun ke islam ke point of view se shares buy karne chahye ya nahi. main kabhi search bhi kiya hai kuch peoples kehte hai islam main mana hai or kuch kehte hai islam main nahi mana. plz jis kissi ko bhi islam ke point of view se sahi pata hai mujhe privatemsg kar ke bata de plzzzzzz.

wahaj
07-09-2012, 06:31 AM
yes,islam me shares ke trading krna halal hai or koi b person share ko but kar skta hai kiun k is me risk hai.jo compnaies halal business karti hain un k ap share buy kar ste ho or un ko sale kar skte hin or pana profit margin nikal skte hain or is lie Islam shares allowed karta hai

kia yeah ap ne kisi aalim ya molvi ya mufti se poocha hai? kyun k yeah koi aisi cheez nh hai k hum aasai he apna opinion dain...aur agr ap ne us se poocha hai toh plx ap se request hai k ap yahan un aalim ka pura jawab post kr dain

adnankhan
07-09-2012, 06:34 AM
mare khayal ma to allowed ha kue ka is ma profit ka sat sat nuqsaan be ha pir be kuch log khate ha k harma ha mager khayal ma kesi ache mufti sa pochna ho ga wase ager hum apni sa kuch kah da to tek nae ha

abbas
07-09-2012, 06:41 AM
shares are haram, but i have herd it some were k shares aik hud tak haram aur halaal hai aur is maamlai mai hamai daikhna hoga k yai kis category mai ayengai.... that all i know about it , i think u should consult a islamic scholar for better answer

petrelsea70
07-09-2012, 08:57 AM
Islam bhot zyda modern religion hain is lie humie tang nazer nhi hona chaie Islam itna tang nazer mazhab naheen hay. Ab ap mujhay ye batain k silver aur gold purchase ker k rakhna jaiz hay ya naheen? Aur ici terha Grain Market walay sara saal different grains stock ker k rakhtay hain

mustafag
07-09-2012, 12:12 PM
Har wo bsiness jis main loss ka khatra ho wo jaiz hay. wo karoobar jis mian siruf profit ho aur ap ki services na hoon wo jaiz nahin hay. but Forex tradin gmian jitna chance profit ka hoota hay utna hi loss ka hoota hay so it is jaiz.

mhanif
07-09-2012, 12:51 PM
doston dekho
agar hum gold,silver buy kartay hay to hamari niyat yay hoti hay k hum isay pehnaingay wagairah
lekin hamari niyat kharab nahi hoti k hum next year ya hum baichay gay jub tak is kay rate barh jaingay

aur jub hum shares buy kartay hay toh hamari niyat yahi hoti hay k jub rates barh jaingay to hum isay baich dengy.

so, mere khayal say islam mein shares haram hay! (mein koi scholar nahi hu aur yay meri zati rai hay)

aur agar kisi dost kay pass reference ho to mujhe zaroor batayega!

Yar main aapki is baat se to sehmat hun. Mujhay bhi ye shares ka sawal bar bar dimagh main ata hai.
Aur aapnay theek kaha regarding Gold Example. Aaj kal log pehentay kam hain aur paisay double karnay k liye zyada khareedte hain GOLD.

huzefakaizer
07-09-2012, 01:24 PM
bhai islam mai jo chez lazmi nam k sath haram kahi gaye hai wo b sub countries mai hoti hai to is mai hamara nafs kiya kehta hai hum ko khud hi us per amal karna hoga

zeb
07-09-2012, 02:14 PM
buying and selling jahan tha mujy lagta ha haram ni hai. kyn k haram wo cheez qarar di hue hai jis py aap ko interest milta hai. and zaroori tou ni k shares ki price upward he move karen yeh downward bhe move kar sakti hain.

syed ahsan
07-10-2012, 03:43 PM
waqai islam itna sakht nahi jitna hum logon ne islam ko banadia hai shares buy ya sale karna islam mein mana nahi hai ap is pe kaam kar sakte hain koi aisi baat nahi hai.

Arsalan.Antique
07-10-2012, 04:32 PM
dekho agar aisi baat hai to islam mai to bohat si chizo ka mana kiya huwa hai us mai hum islam ko beach mai nahi lay kar atay hai per jab business ki baat aati hai to hum molvi ban jatay hai

yar yeh tou logoun ki fitnat hoti he aagr wo khud kuch galat kr rahe hounge tou humme kahingye k nahi yh sahi he and agr hum kuch sahi bhi kr rahe hounge tou hamare raste mein gap paida karaingye k nahi yeh haram he and all

taimur15
07-10-2012, 04:41 PM
yar ye islam yani apne deen ka masla hai mujhe is pr behas nhi krni kiyu k jis bt ka ilam nhi us ko apne pas see nhi kehni chahiye ..yar agr tumhara dil manta hai to kro agr nhi to kisi aalim se pocho ..aur mera khiyal hai aap agr kisi molvi se pocho ge to wo aap ki bt sune bagir hi kahe ga ye hram hai ..mujhe to kisi molvi pr bhi yaqeen nhi hai suchi bbt hai..apne dil ki kro

Smart Boy
07-10-2012, 05:09 PM
yar mje is bare mai nhi pata kuch zada aagr kuch galat bolu to wo bhi sahi nhi ha par mane app logun ka comments parhen kuch kuch samj aaraha ha

fozia
07-10-2012, 05:51 PM
i am still in confusion ke islam main shares buy karna allow hain bhi ya nahi. or maine yahan request bhi ki the ke jis ko sahi knowledge hai is bare main muje orivate message kar ke bata de but no message.

rehman0332
07-10-2012, 05:53 PM
mujy forex ke sheres ke bary me kuch nai pata he magar me bhi forex pe sheres kharidna chata ho aur me ye chata ho ke me forex se hi bohat eanrng karo aur kam time me rich bhan sako aur is waja se me forex pe trading bhi karta ho

huzefakaizer
07-11-2012, 05:20 AM
friend is k baray mai mujhey puri tarha say pata nahi hai to mai is mai koi discusasion nahi kar sakta kyu k aisa na ho k meri waja say kisi aur ko galat fehmi na hajeye aur us ka gunnah b mujhey milay

malik shoaib
07-11-2012, 05:23 AM
yes forex is allowed in islam because islam because islam does not stop you from doing any trade that has equal chance of profit and loss

Junaid1
07-11-2012, 12:51 PM
mjhay bhi is k baaray main zyada nahi pta is liye main is k baray main kuch nahi kahu ga hamain is k liye molvi hazraat se baat krni hahiye...

petrelsea70
07-11-2012, 03:51 PM
islam me trading alow hai aur shares ki trading bhi alow hai ky k is me profit aur loss dono ka risk hota hai.jaise debenture jis per sirf sood milta hai nuqsan ka dar nahi hota to wo islam me haram hai aur shares ki nature difrent hai to wo halal hain

usmanadeel
07-11-2012, 04:58 PM
ye aik religion problem he. aur hm sb log bohat zyada ni jante is bare me. mera khayal k kisi bohat ache se aalm e din se is bare me rahnumaye li jae apne mind se sochna galt he pata ni hum theek hn ya may b galt

fozia
07-11-2012, 05:58 PM
islam me trading alow hai aur shares ki trading bhi alow hai ky k is me profit aur loss dono ka risk hota hai.jaise debenture jis per sirf sood milta hai nuqsan ka dar nahi hota to wo islam me haram hai aur shares ki nature difrent hai to wo halal hain
are u 100% sure ke islam ke point of view se forex trading allow hai or hum shares bhi easily buy kar sakte hain. mostly peoples forex trading ki favour karte hain or mostly is business ke against hain. ofcouse sood to islam main haram hai.

faisal patel
07-11-2012, 06:23 PM
I really don't have any idea about it and if you want to know about this in the right way to phir ap ko kisi deeni kitab ka mutala karna chahye ya phir kisi sharai masail batane wale ulmaa se rabta karna chahye ta k ap ko sahi rehnumai mil sake

BASIT
07-11-2012, 07:34 PM
nai bhai ye to aik buisness hai or shares kharidna islam mai mana nai hai islam itna sakht nai hai jitna molviso nai isy bna dia hai aap agr is cheez mai intrested ho to himmat karo or kaam kardo shuru

rashidkhan
07-12-2012, 04:26 AM
mery khayal se teak hay ye to humny be suna hay kay kay some extent tak halal hay oor kuch had tak haram ha or I think k shares lena haram ha jo kn hamary mazhab mein jaz nahi ha

adnankhan
07-12-2012, 04:30 AM
shares k buying halal ha ya haram is k bare ma maa be bht confuse ho mager apni ray k bajai ager hum kesi ache mufti ka sat is ko discuss kar la to bht acha ho ga

Kashif
07-12-2012, 05:55 AM
bhai is chez k baary main to mujhe bhe bohut se sochen aati hain, par mera dil kehta hai k shares buy karna allowed nahi hoga islam main q k islami banks bhe hamen ziyada profit ya amount increase nahi kar k deti hai, to ye sood hai share khareedna!

mhanif
07-13-2012, 02:00 PM
yar yeh tou logoun ki fitnat hoti he aagr wo khud kuch galat kr rahe hounge tou humme kahingye k nahi yh sahi he and agr hum kuch sahi bhi kr rahe hounge tou hamare raste mein gap paida karaingye k nahi yeh haram he and all

Haan aapki ye baat theek hai . Ye human nature hai, insaan jo khud karta hai woh usko kabhi galat nahi lagta aur agar wohi cheez woh chor de aur koi aur karna shuru karday to galat he bolega.!

Awais
07-13-2012, 02:54 PM
meray khyal say shares k bary mai agar ap ko information chaiye to kisi islamic scholar say pochain wo he ap ko bahtar bata saktay hai hum sab to yahan apna apna point of view share kar saktay hain but zada acha hai k koi properly well known islamic scholar say guid line li jay

areeba009
07-13-2012, 03:20 PM
dekho har insaan ka apna ek nazarya hai lekin mai ek hi baat kahon ga k ham kon hote sahi galat ka faisla karne wale kyun k agar hum hi ne sab kuch karlia to masajid mai jo alim hai to hamain un ki zarorat hi nahin pehle maaloom karlo phr jo karna hai karo.

nihad28
07-13-2012, 05:15 PM
nhi yar shares buy or sale krne me koi gunah nhi hai or na hi ye haram hai mene apne ek dost se ye pocha tha jo mashaallah abhi farigh howa hai os ne mujh se kaha ke ye logon ne apni taraf se afwah pelayi hoti hai .mujhy samaj nhi ata agar ke log q ghalat mashwara dete hai jab unhe pata hi nhi hota os ke bare me.

bbacomsats
07-13-2012, 05:20 PM
mera khayal ma toh ni allow ,. ma sure ni ho, but agar risk hai toh ho skta hai k allow ho qk risk sa busines halal hota , aur yeh baat such hai k debenture aur fixed account toh haram ma ccount hotay hai isleay os say bach k rehna chehya aur hmmey trading pa dehan daina chehya takay hum haalal komai

shahrukh
07-13-2012, 07:16 PM
yar ase to koi bat ni hai k hum shares na kharaden ye islam mein totally jaiz hai k hum kuch bik hrade k use age bexh skte hai usi hisabse share buy or sell krna islam mein jaiz hai

M.zafar
07-13-2012, 09:11 PM
islam itna strict nae jitna logo nay is ko bna diya hei islam mein shars buy krna
koi gunah nae han short selling mein kuch complications hein jo molveh hzrat
kehty hein othr wise no problm in shars buy than sell

Faheem
07-13-2012, 09:15 PM
daikhan mujy is baaat k bary ma zayada knowledge toa nahi ha likin itna zarror kah skta hoon k islam ma itni strickness nahi ha jitna btae gae ha
wasy jahn jahn tak maira khayal ha k shares is allow in islam ku k mainy toa aaj tak kahin b nahi parha ha k shares are not allowed in islam
agr yahi baat ha tab toa sooad b not allowed likin log laity hain tab kahn hota ha on ka islam ?????

juzer12
07-13-2012, 09:34 PM
well ap shares tou kharid sakte ho magar ek bohot zaruri baat hai and you must think about it woh yeh keh jo paisa ap kharch karte ho shares kharidne me kahin woh paisa wohi business me use ho raha hai ya phir use koi aur kaam me lagaya ja raha hai jis se us business ka koi concern hai hi nahi

Usama saad
07-14-2012, 01:00 AM
Mjhe is bare me knowledge bht kam hai but phr be jahan tak mjhe pta hai ke islam me shares buying nd salleing allow hain mene kahen nahi dekha ke islam me shares allow nahi hain infect islam me har jaiz kaam kar sakte hain sub allow hai aur jaiz tareeqe se paisa kamana allow hai najaiz nahi nd shares se jo humain profit milta hai wo humare liye jaiz he hai hum ne us me mehnat k hoti hai

shahzad0able
07-14-2012, 07:38 AM
Islam may shares buy kerna allow hay laykin aap ye cheez daykh lain kay jiss company kay shares aap buy ker rahay hain wo kisi aesi cheez ka karobaar to nae ker rahi jo Islam may haraam ho.

Raja Aqeel Ahmad
07-14-2012, 07:44 AM
SAB SAY PHLI BAAT AP JIS PRODUCT K SHARE LY RAHY HO US KO MAD E NAZAR RAKOO SUPPOSE AGAR KOI SHARAB KI COMPANY K SHARE HA TO WO HALAL NI HA AUR 2RI BAAT IS MA RISK HA LOSS KA TO SHARE WAISY HALAL HA BUT YAR IS MA AGAR PROFIT HAD SAY ZIADA HA TO B HARAM AUR WAISY MJY BHOT ZIADA NI PTA SO IS K BARY MA MOLVI HAZTRAT HI CONFIRM KAR SAKTY HA

XDLOVERS
07-14-2012, 12:48 PM
sayad allowed nahi hai !but i am not sure !
aap ek kaam kyun nahi karte aap direct kjake apke manager sai contact karlo woh aapko sahi information dega !

shiekh saim
07-15-2012, 05:14 AM
g mairy khayal say toa share buying iz allowed in ISLAM ku k ya koi buri cheez nahi ha joa ISLAM hmaian is say mana kary mujy toa shares buying ma koi galt baat nazar nahi aati ha agar kisi ko nazar aati ha toa plz share with us ?/'

dbtanoli
07-15-2012, 05:25 AM
dost islam aik deen hay or usay deen-e-fitret bhi kaha jata hay her us company kay shares khareedna or sell kerna jaiz hay jo physically kahin mojood hoyani us ko kahin na kahin zameen per majood hona zarori hay ,,ager company physically mojood hay to trading jaiz ager virtually hay to phir islam us ko jaiz nahin karar dayta yeh maira zati khyal hay is ko herf-e-akhir na shamja jay

Kashif
07-15-2012, 05:31 AM
Walikum asslam, agar islamic point of view se dekha jae to share buy karny ki ijaazat nahi hai islam main q k share buy karna, like sood khana hai to share buy karna islamic point of view se to ghalat hai par ajkal log islam ko kahan follow karty hai? sab log apni apni karty hai bus roti chahiye unko wo halal ki ho ya haram ki pait bhar jaata hai!

misssoozy
07-15-2012, 05:31 AM
shares k buy kernay k baray mai hm to koi fatwa ni dai saktay lakin ye hai k hm sirf poch saktay hai kisi mufti hazrat sai k islam mai es ka kiya concept hai.

Arsalan.Antique
07-15-2012, 08:32 AM
harwo cheez har wo kaam jis mein aapki mehnat nahi lagi kuch effort nahi laga us se aapko paisa mil rha he tou wo haram he allowed nahi he and har wo cheez har wo kaam jis mein apki mehnat lagi he apka efort laga he us ka paisa halal he or allowed he

Rashid Ali
07-15-2012, 10:36 AM
i think itna strict islam nae jitna logo nay is ko bna diya hei islam mein shars buy krna
koi gunah nae han short selling mein kuch complications hein jo molve hzrat
kehty hein lekin pher b zeyada mein nai janta

danishdk
07-16-2012, 01:56 PM
main arsalan ki baat sy agree karu ga k ap ju be kaam karu or us main ap k khud ki effort shamil hain then woh halal hian otherwise haram hain jaha tk share ka sawal hain tu main is bary main kuch khas nai kah sakta

shahzad0able
07-23-2012, 12:28 AM
Shares ko buy sell kerna jaeez hay, ye kisi bhi cheez ki tarah hotay hain kay aap investment ki sooch rakh ker shares lay lain aur kuch weeks ya months kay baad kuch high price per sell ker kay profit kama lain.

waqas_khan9222
07-23-2012, 06:05 AM
islam busness krne se ni rokta han islam sooud se zaror rokta ha to mery khl ma asi koi bat ni ha shears r buy ma q k is se kisi ka haq to ni mara jata balke ap to apni mehnat se sb krty ho r isla hamien mehnat ki takqeen krta ha so carry on

darknight
07-23-2012, 12:39 PM
muja khud is k bare ma sahe malomat nae ha ka share allowed ha ka nae islam ma may na bht logo sa be pocha mager mager muja sahe malomat kesi na nae di

farooq
07-23-2012, 03:17 PM
yar as far as i think hamin itna serious nai discuss kar k apna opnion daina chaiye hamin yee kisi aalam e d se consult karna chayieeen

taimoor qureshi
07-23-2012, 03:55 PM
sir jaha tak mene suna hai to ye sub cheezain islam me haram hain q k islam me is cheez ka koi concept nahi hai.lekin bohat se islamis mumalik me ye share log buy kartah hain.

rabeel
07-24-2012, 05:15 AM
yar as far as i think hamin itna serious nai discuss kar k apna opnion daina chaiye hamin yee kisi aalam e d se consult karna chayieeen
Rite this is a good approach kun kh is kay bary main koe relegious scholar hy bta sakta ha aur agar ap personal oponion ke baat kro tu ap apni capibilities cy market understand krtay hoa aur is main apko just profit ne loss bhe usy tarh hota ha aur ap uncertain hotay ho.

sali
07-24-2012, 05:35 AM
Islam give us complete code of life. its also tells us to do business and make illegal money. However what the Islam says about he shares, i don't know about and i will be get knowledge of it form religious scholar.

syedaasmabi
07-24-2012, 10:01 AM
share ka buy kar na jaiz nahi hai ,woh ku? ku app ko is per mukamal qabza nahi hota app is ko just apney computer ki screen per dekh rahy hoty hain,so isterhan ya karobar sahi nahi hai ,Forex mey ager app ke pass kisi country ke currency cash hai or app khud usey apney hath se kisi money exchange mey sell karney jatey hain to ya sahi hai .

darknight
07-24-2012, 11:26 AM
islam ma shares allowed ha ka nae ager ye sawal hum kesi ache alam ya mufti sar kar la to zayda acha ho ga kue ka yahan kesi ko is ka bare ma pata nae ha

altafa50
07-25-2012, 02:06 AM
share ki haqiqat aik kuch nahi app ko sirf bata diya jata hai ya just app ko aik online account open kar ke app ki computer screen per dikha diya jata hai app ke pass itney shares hai.laykin ya app ke handover ya ap key qabzey mein nahi hoty so ya karobar JAIZ NAHI HAI.

Emran Ali
07-26-2012, 12:25 PM
im not sure, but muje nahi lagta k yeh ghuna hai i think is se kai rozgar judre huwe hain or isi se kai ghar chal rehey hai, profit or loss to har kam main hota hi hai to specaily shares ko kun indicate kia gia hai is main muje bhi packki information nahi is bare main.

Jawwad
07-26-2012, 01:05 PM
i have not enough knowledge about that.... per suni sunae baat hai kafi log kehte hain k share but krna allow nhe hai islam me.. i am not sure about it.

petrelsea70
07-26-2012, 01:23 PM
islam allow krta hai bahi Waqai Islam itna tang nazer mazhab naheen hay. Ab ap mujhay ye batain k silver aur gold purchase ker k rakhna jaiz hay ya naheen? Aur ici terha Grain Market walay sara saal different grains stock ker k rakhtay hain aur mehangi honay per baich daitay hain to kia ye bhi najaiz hay

sher abbas
07-26-2012, 01:46 PM
topic se hut ke sawal hy any way ISLAM men shares ki buying or selling allow hy , sirf ye ki wo shares halal companies ki ho or dusri baat halal companies ke sath sath us company ke uper yek certain ratio interest na ho agr us company ke uper loan interest ke uper hy to un companies per trade ni kr skty .
2ndly shares position pe kr skty hen short selling allow ni hy yani shares aap ke qabzey men aani chahy or apni qbzy se hi aap sell kerskty hen.

fozia
07-26-2012, 03:54 PM
islam main shares buy or sell karna allow hain or islam main is ko na karne ki koi restriction nahi hai. islam main forex traing karna halal hai. is liye humain without any tension trading karni chahye.

zeb
07-26-2012, 04:14 PM
muja khud is k bare ma sahe malomat nae ha ka share allowed ha ka nae islam ma may na bht logo sa be pocha mager mager muja sahe malomat kesi na nae di

shares buy karna islam main allowed hai. kynn k shares py interset ni milta balky jo amount aap ko zaida milti hai wo profit consider kiya jata hai aur agar kam mily tou loss.

Rehan Hashmat
07-30-2012, 05:35 AM
mery khiyal sy shares ka business halal hai q k is mein interest nahi milta or ap ko profit hony k sath sath loss b hota hai..but kuch log is ko halaal nahi samajty..

Emran Ali
07-30-2012, 05:41 AM
Profit or Loss har business main hota hai, Islam ne ek haad tak chout di huwi hai, aghar us haad ko cross karo gay to haram main aajye ga or seriously kam karo gay or apni rozi roti ka zarya banao gay to phir muje nahi lagta k galat hai...

waqasashraf17
07-30-2012, 06:39 AM
doston! as salam o alaikum
mein yahan har roz aata hu to meri nazar shares par parti hay jis mein likha hota hay k 'we buy' and 'we sell'
dekh kar lagta hay aur mind kehta hay k shares kharid lo agay shares kay rate barhaingay aur is say acha profit hosakta hay.
Lekin mera dil kehta hay k 'nahi! yay allow nahi hay islam mein'

kya aap meri madad karaingay? please!
mujhe thora sa guide kardain. :sm21: :sm48:


es bat ka tu mujhay achi tarha pata nh hai k ya islam ma allow hai ja nh magar merykhial ma ya allow hai kyu k es main loss or profit k equal chances hai so it is allow in islam.or hum share ko buy kr saktay hai magar ya confirm nh hai.

Arsalan.Antique
07-30-2012, 06:55 AM
i think aisey maslay ka solution poochnay ka sab se betreen jaga /tariqah ye ha keh banda kisi aalim se ja kr is baray me pooch lian keh shares purchase/sale halaaal ha or haram? ap ko yahan se valid answer mushkil ha amilay.

yar mjhe aik bat samjh nahi ati, kya hum khud es bat ka solution nahi dhundh sakhte? har bat aalim se puchna zaroori he? wese theek he ha k agr apppko janna ho tou aap jan sakhte ho lekin mere khyl se agr hum khud es ko dhundhe tou zyda acha rehega

darknight
07-30-2012, 10:37 AM
han share ka bare ma kesi ko sahe malomat nae ha ka ye islam ma allowed ha ka nae mare khayal ma apni ray ki jaga ager hum kesi ache mufti sa poch la to acha ho ga

sher abbas
07-30-2012, 02:27 PM
bhai shares ka kaam heraam nehi hey, kunki yeh kaam puri dunya mein hota hey aur even k saudia arab mien bhi ho reha hey isi liye is ko haraam kehna ghelt hey aur ager kisi ko doubt hey to us ko chahiye woh share na purchase keray

Sir Islam men haram ya halal dunya men ksi cheez ka hona ya na hony se ni hota hy balki kuch principles Islam ney define key hen un ko agr voilate key jay to haram hen or agr follow kia jey to Halal. Interest puri dunya men aam hy but Islam men haram hy ??

mobin207
07-30-2012, 02:35 PM
Yes my dear you can buy shares and it is allowed in Islam it is totally called halal in Islam so don't be panic try to invest in mutual sharing programs it can give you profit also.

Kssaim
07-30-2012, 02:41 PM
Mere khyal se shares haram nai hai q k jab hum koi b kaam kartey hai to profit ki neyat se hi kartey hai to jab hum shares par invest kartey hai to ic pe profit q nai hona chahiey

zeb
07-30-2012, 03:11 PM
yar mjhe aik bat samjh nahi ati, kya hum khud es bat ka solution nahi dhundh sakhte? har bat aalim se puchna zaroori he? wese theek he ha k agr apppko janna ho tou aap jan sakhte ho lekin mere khyl se agr hum khud es ko dhundhe tou zyda acha rehega

main aap ki baat sy agree ni karti. agar kisi bat ki jankari leni hai aap ko tou usska better soulution yahi hota hai k kisi aisy shakhs sy poocha jaye jis ko uss bary main ilam ho.

taimoor qureshi
07-30-2012, 05:58 PM
sir me b is baray me yahi khao k islam hame galat kaam se mana karta hai par forex meto kuch galat nahi hota hai.yaha ksi k sth dhoka nahi hai har koi apni mehnat se paisa kama rahahi yaha pe.

iqbalmbs44
07-30-2012, 06:01 PM
mera nai khyaal ke shares ka kaam islam ma haram ha kiou ke aik to ye all over the world allowed ha or dosra is se ap ko profit earn hota ha.

usman
07-31-2012, 02:04 AM
Islam aik boaht wasee mazah hy hmary han kuch loon na is ko asa bna kar pash kia hy jis sa lgta hy ka asa karna galt hy Islam ma shares kharidny pa koi pabandi nhi hy ap jasy chahin sell or buy kar skty hyn.

rabeel
07-31-2012, 05:50 AM
main aap ki baat sy agree ni karti. agar kisi bat ki jankari leni hai aap ko tou usska better soulution yahi hota hai k kisi aisy shakhs sy poocha jaye jis ko uss bary main ilam ho.

True ! its better to take the oponion of an alim , kun kh humain atna ilm ne ha aur humain itna market ka ne pta kh iss main exactly kya ho rha ha so humain cahahey kh hum kisi authentic cy sawal krain.

Arsalan.Antique
07-31-2012, 07:46 AM
islam main shares purchase krna halal he pr is surat main k ap us ka profit ya loss earn kro ge. agr is lye purchase kro k rate brhne pr sale kr do ge to ye halal nhi he. I have strong comment about it. mene ye kisi book main prha he.

kya matlb he apka dost? k mei zara hi nahi samjh saka, koi bewaqoof he hoga jo loss mei bechne ka sochega, mei tou hamesha profit he dekhunga, and in my opinion har wo cheez halal he jis mei apka effort laga ho apki mehnat lagi ho

Awais
07-31-2012, 08:10 AM
yep difinitly byuing shares is allowd in islam becoz jab ap share purchase kartay ho kisi compny say to compny ap k paiso say business karti hai or phr jitna profti hota hai wo ap ko day daitay hain

fozia
07-31-2012, 09:36 AM
yes buying and selling shares in islam is allowed. hum forex trading pe aram se trade kar sakte hain islam nay humain trade karne se mana nahi kiya hua. is main humain acha profit mil raha hai r yeh bilkul halal kam hai.

Smart Boy
07-31-2012, 10:05 AM
bahi mera hisab sa to hme ya thread pa zada kuch kehna bhi nhi chaye kia pata hm galat hn is pa bt karna sa pehla kisi bare sa pochna parega phr hi bt karni chaye

mustafag
07-31-2012, 01:24 PM
Har wo karrobar jis mian loss ho sakta hoo wo jaiz hay. is leye share buy karna theek hay islami point of view say , is mian koi haraj nahin jhay.

zetsu
07-31-2012, 01:56 PM
main to ye kehna chahun ga k jis tarha ap aik zameen lety hain or kuch arsy baad us zameen ka rate pehly sy bht ziada barh jata hai jo baad men ap sell kr k acha khaasa profit kamaaty hain. . is sy to islam manaa nhe krta. . isi tarha shares k b ye he scene hai. . .i think k islams ny in k baary men koi stricktness nhe ki

bbacomsats
07-31-2012, 02:13 PM
yes buying is alot, dekho yar shares jo hai wo basicaly ik ap share ly rhy hai forex ka aur isma apko risk hota hai k wo sasta hojai aur apko loss dy jai islea jis busines ma risk hoga mera khyl sa wo halal hai aur islam ka point of view b yehe hoga baki ma koi ulma ni k mujay exact pata ho

syed ahsan
07-31-2012, 04:02 PM
waqayi mere dost aapne sahi kahan kay islam itna strict nahi hain jitna humne banadia hai isko. bilkul aap shares sale and buy kar sakte hain magar ek limit mein profit rakh k jitna fair hai.

Kashif
07-31-2012, 04:47 PM
buying shares isn't allowed in ISLAM, & trading bhe allow nahi hai ISLAM main par wo to hamen bhe pata hai k log to aj kal paise k lye qatal tak kar lety hai to trading hum kar rahy hai to muaf karny wala ALLAH hai agar job nahi milegi to log trading he karengy na bhok to nahi marna hai na!

shiekh saim
08-01-2012, 07:51 AM
mairy khayal say toa ISLAM ma aisi koi b pabandi nahi ha k shares buying nahi kar skty hain ku k ya koi bura kaam nahi ha joa k ISLAM hamian mana kary is kaam say

RASHEED
08-01-2012, 09:41 AM
Ji Islam min share ke koi pabandi nhi hai kuen ke ye sood se bahut different hai. Is main ye hai ke ager company ko profit ho raha hai to wo profit distribute kre gy otherwise nhi. Is liye hum investment krte hain or investment krne se islam rokta nhi hai.

rabeel
08-01-2012, 09:57 AM
yes buying is alot, dekho yar shares jo hai wo basicaly ik ap share ly rhy hai forex ka aur isma apko risk hota hai k wo sasta hojai aur apko loss dy jai islea jis busines ma risk hoga mera khyl sa wo halal hai aur islam ka point of view b yehe hoga baki ma koi ulma ni k mujay exact pata ho

Exactly i agree app ka business main profit:loss same proportion cy hota ha aur apko just profit hy ne hota. secondly ap apni personal koshish cy bhe bht kuch earn kar saktay ho aur ap iss main bohat ka homework bhe kraty ho so it has more chances to be valid.

faraz
08-01-2012, 10:14 AM
Exactly, Islam itna strict hai naien jitna logon ne ise banaya wa hai aur profit aur loss wali tamam activities allowed hain. So, shares khareedne bhi allowed hain. Mein yahan tamam bhaion se itafaq karna chahon ga.

zetsu
08-01-2012, 10:15 AM
bhai shares k baray men kafi doubt ha k ye haram han ya hilal, but men ne apnay parents se pocha tha and aik article bhi parha tha is k baray men k ye islam ki nazar men thek nai ha, but is trading men loss bhi hota ha so jis chez men loss ho wo halal he hoti ha lekin hm kuch confirm keh nai sktay

fozia
08-01-2012, 11:02 AM
bhai shares k baray men kafi doubt ha k ye haram han ya hilal, but men ne apnay parents se pocha tha and aik article bhi parha tha is k baray men k ye islam ki nazar men thek nai ha, but is trading men loss bhi hota ha so jis chez men loss ho wo halal he hoti ha lekin hm kuch confirm keh nai sktay
han g i agree with you ke islam main forex trading halal hai kyun ke forex trading main humain profit or loss dono hota hai to islam main yeh haram kese ho sakta hai. mujhe bhi ap ki tarah confusion the but ab meri confusion clear ho gaye hai.

FAHAD10
08-01-2012, 11:09 AM
is bare mein mujhe itni information nai hai . ek baat suni hai ke " jis cheez mein loss aur profit dono ho wo sahi hai " but mein ye confirm nai keh sakta ke ye halal hai ya haram hai .

faisal patel
08-01-2012, 11:22 AM
is bare ma kuch idea to nahi ha but jaha tk suna ha shares ma ap ko jo uper paise milte ha woh is lia k ap ne company ma invest kiye hote ha or un ki kamai ha hise dar hote ha ap to I think ye allowed honge but kuch cnfrm nahi keh skta.

waqasashraf17
08-01-2012, 11:30 AM
yes ap bilkul thk kah rahay ho agar ap ko doubt ho tu ap ko wo kam karna hi nh karna cahiyay magar mery khial ma ya halal hai aur hum shares buy kar saktay hai aur es sa earn ar saktay aur may be loss bi ho sakta hai.

Anwer Rangoonwala
08-01-2012, 03:33 PM
islam mai shares ka karobaar jaaiz hai lekin jis company k shares liye ja rahe hai uska kaam halal tareekey se hota ho...
aur shares lene ka tareeka ye hai k aap jis company k shares le rahe hai aap us shares ki poori amount pay karke us k owner bane...

Maria Arsalan
08-01-2012, 04:18 PM
Well jahan tak shares ki bat hai islam mn toe mn itna janti hun k islam mn khareed o farookhth allow hai
ap phr is trhan share ki buying or selling kro

sher abbas
08-01-2012, 05:45 PM
han g islam men shares ki kharidari jaiez hy kuch sharayet ke sath , jin companies ki shares purchase kr rahy hen wo halal product pe deal kr rahi hon, yani sharab, ya gambling se related companies ni honi chahy.

taimoor qureshi
08-01-2012, 05:55 PM
sir g..mere khayal me forex me kisi k dath fraud nahi hota na hi be insafi hoti hai to ye phir kaise galat ho sakta hai islam me..or hum apni mehnat ka k paisa kama rahay hain forex se.

Kashif
08-01-2012, 09:43 PM
Walikum asslam, Islam main shares kharedna allow nahi hia & ye sood hai par ye apny dekha hoga k sood to aj kal aam ho gae hai sb karty hai par main to kabhe bhe shares buy nahi karny wala hun forex main!

mohsin shakeel
08-01-2012, 10:02 PM
w salaam ye to ap boht acha krty hy lekin ap agr ye hi sawl ksi allim sy puchy to wo ap ko achi trha gaide kr skty hy or wese bi aj kl ky lrky kaha islaam ki baty janty hy wo to bs awara hy .

shahzad0able
08-02-2012, 12:15 AM
assalamo alaikum.. bhai shares ka kam haram kaise ho skta hay.. is ma nafa or nuqsan dono hain, han mehnat wali bt pr thora doubt hay, koi ap ma se asa hy jisy iski full knowledge ho with refrnce

Islam may shares ka karoobaar haraam iss tarah ho sakta hay kay agar app kisi aesi company kay shares purchase karain jo kisi haraam cheez ka karobaar kerti hay to phir wo shares ki kamae bhi jaeez nae hogi.

altafa50
08-02-2012, 02:23 AM
JEE NAHI ISLAM MEY SHARES KA BUY KARNA JAIZE NAHI HAI ,KU YA AIK AYSI CHEEZ HAI JIS PER APP QABZA NAHI KARSAKTEY OR KAORBAR KE LIYA YA LAZMI HAI KE JO CHEEZ APP BUY YA SELL KAR RAHY HO US PER APP KA QABZA HONA ZARORI HAI.

Eagle
08-02-2012, 09:57 AM
it is better tu ask a muslim scholar. ap aik alim say pachy. ye ap comments logo say nahy lah sak thy hai. kui kay is forum par har bandah alam nahy hai.

shiekh saim
08-03-2012, 03:18 PM
mairy khyal say toa agar hum gold,silver buy kartay hay to hamari niyat yay hoti hay k hum isay pehnaingay wagairah
lekin hamari niyat kharab nahi hoti k hum next year ya hum baichay gay jub tak is kay rate barh jaingay
aur jub hum shares buy kartay hay toh hamari niyat yahi hoti hay k jub rates barh jaingay to hum isay baich dengy.
so, mere khayal say islam mein shares haram hay! (mein koi scholar nahi hu aur yay meri zati rai hay)
aur agar kisi dost kay pass reference ho to mujhe zaroor batayega!

haseebullah
08-03-2012, 07:16 PM
je waisia mearea khayal sea yeh islam mai jaz nai hai kuey kea yeh bhi aik kism ka jua hai magar mujhea is barea mai itna ilm nai hai mai confirm kar kea bata skta ho?

hasnu_akw1987
08-03-2012, 08:19 PM
nahi bahi aisa nahi hai k shares buy karna islam main mana hai .. ye baat bilqul galat hai islam main trade jayez hai bus gambling karna mana hai ... stock market main shares k purchasing main gambling b hoti hai short selling aur buy back karna ye sab islam main mana hai baqi sab theek hai

virani
08-03-2012, 09:50 PM
Sawal Islam kay mutabik hai. Aap ye sochay kay business may kay profit nehi hota issi tarah shares market may bhi khabi profit or khabi loss hota hai. Islam ki rooh kay mutabik meray khayal say shares buy and sell kar saktay hain. Lakin agar shares buy kartay hai tuh kuch din tak hold karay tuh acha hai. Islam may is ki izajat hai. Aur baad may is say sell kar saktay hai. chahiye ap ko munafa ho ye nuksaan.

nahiyar
08-03-2012, 10:51 PM
In Short,Agar aap ka swap free account hai, yaani aap kisi b qisam ka koi interest de ya le nahi rahe hai on execution,running and closing of trades/positions, to ISLAM mai aisa her trade kernay ki ijazat hai..

The topic has been discussed too much, and there is no need to let it to be further discussed.Hence, it is being closed..